Date: August 7, 2011
SUNDAY: Ordinary 19A, Proper 14
SERMON: Walking on Water
Text(s): Matthew 14:22-33
© 2011 R. F. Small
When I told her the passage I was preaching on, Leslie said, “Huh. I don’t think I’ve ever heard a sermon on that before!” When I thought about it, neither had I. Not surprising, since it contains one of the most unbelievable stories in Scripture. But it occurs to me that to dismiss this story is a shame, because while it is unbelievable, it is, in another way, very true.
Does this story of Peter walking on water feel familiar to any of you? Now, I don’t mean, have you ever actually walked on water... Although, if you have, please raise your hand and then come on up here, because you’re going to give the sermon!
But I mean, have you ever been given the power to do something that felt impossible because you called on God’s power to help you?
Peter has sort of become the head disciple at this point in the Gospel, which happens right after the miracle of the loaves and fishes. He is eager to please, eager to follow, but also scared in a boat full of scared people. He gets just enough courage to ask for direction from God, and lo and behold, the direction is laid before him.
On faith, he steps onto the water, wind whipping around him. His focus is clear. He has been called by Jesus to do something amazing! His eyes are on the prize: Jesus, his teacher, his guide, his Lord.
His eyes are focused, anyway, until the wind whips just right across his face, and draws his attention with it. Suddenly, it is no longer the reassuring face of his friend and mentor and teacher that he is looking upon, but crashing waves and dense fog. And his feet are trying to walk on water!
In that moment of lost focus, chaos wins, and Peter begins to sink. It is then, when he has realized that all control is lost, that he is no longer a “faithful disciple” and the chief among his peers, but a man with the tar scared out of him that is about to drown – it is then that he calls out not for Jesus to give him a tall order of a task, but simply to help him, to save him.
 |
Peter being saved. Note the giant waves, and scared ship-full of disciples. Image borrowed from this page. |
This story reminds me of one of these moments in my own life. It was one of the first times I ever truly prayed, ever truly asked for God to do with me as Thou wouldst (when you’re that desperate, you’re willing to use Old English!).
It was my first summer as a church camp counselor, a job I thought would be a fun way to spend the summer. Never mind that I had very little experience with children, except for some carefully honed door-slamming skills when faced with the visage of my little brother.
Our training week as camp counselors really built us up, helped us feel like rock stars. We were going help these children develop a deep faith in God, and we were going to have fun doing it!
At the end of the week, they gave out assignments for which counselors would be assigned to which camps. I was nervous, but faithful. I was really hoping for the elementary ages, because they were the cutest.
They had assured us that new counselors would be paired with experienced counselors for the first week, to help us ease into things. What I didn’t notice was that there was one more new counselor than there were experienced counselors. Nor did I notice that, to fill that hole, we’d be getting in an adult volunteer. And that that volunteer and one other counselor would be sent away from camp for the week with 17 middle-schoolers for a biking trip. I didn’t notice any of this, because I was busy preparing myself to be a great counselor of elementary students.
Imagine my surprise when I, a rookie counselor, was called up as the lone staff counselor on the bike trip. Fear started to set in. As I stepped out of the boat of my fellow fearful followers and into the ocean of the 15-passenger van of hormones that I had to drive for the week, I heard the wind whipping around me. And yet, I maintained my focus. I believed I could do it. I put on my big-girl bandana and drove off into the sunset.
After sunset, though, things got tough. A carsick girl exploded all over the van. The church kitchen we had to cook our meals in only had one burner that worked, which made our spaghetti very time-consuming and encouraged a lot of whining. Then, my co-counselor then dropped the bomb on me: he didn’t feel like he could lead any of the devotional stuff. He’d like to leave that up to me, since I was trained in it. Gasp!
I gathered the troops for grace. They talked through the whole thing, ignoring me. After dinner and cleanup, I gathered them again for vespers. Everything I tried was declared “dumb” or worse. My co-counselor looked on silently, with what I could only assume was scornful judgment.
As we climbed into our beds, which in this case meant each of us having an individual pew in the sanctuary of the church that was hosting us, tears were rolling down my face. I was no longer a superhero counselor. I no longer felt faithful. I only felt a frantic sinking feeling, and a desperate need for help. I began to pray. Helplessly, I begged God to save me. I said I would do whatever was necessary, if God would just help me survive this week. I prayed until I slept, until the winds calmed.
The next morning, I awoke with a new sense of peace and confidence. I wasn’t sure where it came from – well, I was, but was kind of afraid to admit it. I went with it. I led the morning prayers and didn’t hear a peep of complaints (maybe because they were all really tired from horsing around all night). Suddenly, it occurred to me that these kids I had been sent to serve might actually want someone to pay attention to them. I began listening to the campers, getting to know them and their stories, and I altered my games and prayers to fit their context.
Before I knew it, I was really doing it – I was really being a counselor! I had been saved!
The week was by no means perfect, and on those West Virginia roads I surely hadn’t seen the last of carsickness, but from that morning on, I no longer felt alone. I knew I had help, a source of power greater than myself, a true God to turn to.
This same story has happened for me numerous times in life, over and over because I have to learn this lesson over and over, this lesson that God is faithful and present, willing and able to help if I will ask. I regularly repeat the process of trying to follow, then taking pride in my own sense of control, then being distracted by the chaos of life and falling into deep fear, and finally, finally, asking for true help, no strings attached.
I wonder if this story resonates for you, too. I wonder if you have had moments of feeling like you were really trying to do the right thing, to follow God’s calling, to be the best disciple you could be, only to have fear and trembling crumble you into a sinking mess. I wonder if you have found yourself begging for help, being willing to do whatever is necessary just to be saved from the current circumstances. Willing to pray with all your heart.
Anne Lamott, one of my favorite writers, says that there are only really two prayers: “Thank you thank you thank you” and “Help me help me help me.” Often it takes these times of great distress to force us onto our proverbial – or maybe even literal – knees, begging for God’s help.
If we go back and think about the story a bit more, we realize that Peter and Jesus are not the only characters in this story. There is a whole boatload of disciples watching this scene unfold, too. These are the ones who never wanted to step out of the boat, never had the hubris to think that they, too, could walk on water, and in fact were simply just dumbstruck by the whole scene, pretty sure it was some kind of nightmare.
As they watched Peter take his life into his hands, what were they praying? Were they praying at all? Did they really think that Jesus could do such things, even though they had just witnessed him feed 5,000 people on a few loaves of bread and a couple of fish? It seems that they did not believe that it was possible. They stayed huddled on the boat, watching.
Plus, the disciples weren’t just afraid of the storm. They were afraid of Jesus, too. When he came strolling over to them on top of the waves, they were probably MORE scared of him than the roiling sea. At least they knew what to expect in a storm! The divine incarnate is another matter. Several of them probably would have liked to be able to walk on water just to be able to run away from Jesus. Like many of us, believing in a supernatural miracle-worker might have felt to them far crazier than simply dying in a storm.
Jesus recognizes this and shouts to them: “Be not afraid. It is I.” He uses a key phrase here that can be translated both “It is I” and “I AM,” I AM being the holy name of God. Jesus was both invoking the power of God and being the power of God. It was scary.
It’s not until both Jesus and Peter are back in the boat and drying off that the disciples begin to identify this man as the Son of God. As they watched the scene unfold, you know they were wondering if Peter would survive. But Jesus proved himself to be not only more powerful than they had imagined, but also more gracious. When Peter doubted, faltered, Jesus did not let him languish. He immediately reached out to help as soon as Peter asked for it. He used his power to save Peter’s life, and in so doing, also saved the spiritual lives of everyone on that boat.
As a group of people changed by witnessing the power of the holy in someone’s life, the disciples here remind me of a story told by the church I attended in Seattle.
It was 1980, and the winds were whipping up on the United Methodist Church around issues of human sexuality. The Council, what we would call the General Board, was approached by a quiet man in his 40s named Chuck.
Chuck had recently been divorced, but now seemed to have a new joy about him. He told the Council his story, of how his wife had left him, and he had been so grief-stricken that he had prayed desperately for god’s help. As months went by his grief slowly lifted, and he began to make new friends. With one friend, he found a deep connection, deeper than he’d ever known in his life. He realized that he was deeply in love -- with a man.
It was like a new world of joy had opened up to him, and he believed God had given him a true gift.
Now, surrounded by the rocking of the boat of of church policy, Chuck asked the Council to take a public stand against the denomination’s policies and the city’s new law that gay teachers like Chuck could be fired for coming out of the closet.
The Council was silent for a few minutes. Then, the Council’s resident curmudgeon -- every church has at least one! -- stood up. Standing was not a regular practice a these casual meetings. Everyone held their breath.
Then, the curmudgeon said, “I have seen a transformation in Chuck that seems to me like the work of God. And who are we to go against the work of God?” He sat back down.
As the next hour unfolded, the other Council members told their own stories feeling lost and out of control, only to be saved by a power greater than themselves.
They voted unanimously to take the stand that Chuck had asked them to take. By the time I was a member of that church, 20 years later, they were well-known in the city as a church on the vanguard of LGBT rights, as well as many other issues of social justice. By witnessing the salvation of one of their members, the whole church had been saved. And this gave them the power to bring that saving grace to others, just like the disciples in that boat eventually did for thousands of others.
All of this happened because one man was courageous -- or maybe, faithful -- enough, to try walking on water. And even when that became too hard, he was able to ask for help. This act, witnessed by other frightened people, transformed their understanding of God’s power, and in turn transformed their ministry to others.
Whether you identify more with Peter or the disciples, there is good news for you in this story. Both are saved. Now, lest you think I’m getting all southern Baptist on you and am about to preach hellfire and damnation, let me assure that my understanding of salvation is in a much more practical sense. I’m talking instead about real, in-the-moment, right-here-on-earth salvation.
In the Gospel, the disciples were saved from death by drowning. In our regular lives, we are often in need of saving from both literal and figurative storms. We find ourselves in need of saving in the midst of deep debt, relational turmoil, helplessness in the face of injustice, uncontrollable pride. We need salvation from fear, anxiety, and suffering. We are a people in constant need of saving, because we are humans, and we mess up, and we are affected by others who mess up, too.
And the good news of this story is that God, as revealed in the person of Jesus, is capable of that saving grace, and waits for us to call out and ask for it. Even greater is the good news that God is not just there to save an individual, like Peter. Through the ways that God works in one person’s life and we in the boat are there to witness it, we too are saved. We, too, grow in our faith that God might actually be able to help us, if God could help that sap, Peter. Perhaps, if we ask for it, we might even be able to walk on water long enough to help others get a glimpse of that faith as well.
Who could we become, all of us together on this ship of stormy times in the economy, embroiled in many wars, with the widest gap between rich and poor ever seen in this country? Who could we become, as a church facing generational shifts and their accompanying undercurrents of conflict?
Who could we become if a few of us trusted enough to step out of the boat, relying solely on God’s power? Who could we become, as a church, if we witness that power, hear those stories, let ourselves be changed? Imagine what might be possible!
Imagine if we shared with each other the stories of facing unemployment or an underwater mortgage, and a job coming through at the last minute... Might the church, witnessing to this power of God, be moved to form a job resource center, or ban together for affordable housing? Imagine if one of us were to share her experience of being liberated through divorce from an abusive relationship, and we found ourselves with renewed vigor to advocate for others who’ve been abused...
Whether we are like Peter, eager to take a risk on the power of God, or simply witnesses to Peter’s faith journey on the water, can we open ourselves to the possibility that maybe, just maybe, with God’s love and power, it is possible to walk on water?
Could we, as William Sloane Coffin once put it, decide to commit as much of ourselves to as much of God as we can believe in, and see what happens? As we face our next storms, let us be not afraid, but call upon the great I AM to save us, and watch what happens!